After reading through Slaughter-house Five, respond to the questions posed below the infographic:
Questions:
Does the narrator have more freedom than the character of Billy Pilgrim to control the past, present, or future?
Do you as the reader have more freedom than the character of Billy Pilgrim to control the past, present, or future?
Can there be human purpose/meaning without human control?
If determinism is true what is the "cost" or impact at a societal level?
Dosteovsky & Notes From Underground
Click on the image to access the online version of "Notes From Underground". Read part 1 - don't worry; it is very short :-)
Questions:
In section 3 of part 1, Dosteovsky uses a "stone wall" to represent determinism. How does he preserve a sense of free will within the section? Is the sense that is preserved adequate?
In section 4 of part 1, Dosteosky explores the significance of a toothache. Seriously! What philosophical purpose does the toothache serve?
Consider the final two sentences of section 7 in part 1: What has made them conceive that man must want a rationally advantageous choice? What man wants is simply INDEPENDENT choice, whatever that independence may cost and wherever it may lead. And choice, of course, the devil only knows what choice.How is Dosteovsky attacking determinism through rationality in this section?